Would You Pay to Park On Your Block?

A bill passed by the City Council may make it difficult to park where you don't live in the city, but easier to park where you live—if you're willing to pay.

A proposal from a Brooklyn state senator may make it easier to park on your block, but it’ll cost you.

The bill, written by Sen. Daniel Squadron would allow people living in a neighborhood to purchase special permits to park in the area. At least twenty percent of space will be saved for non-residents to park in 90-minute clips.

The bill passed the City Council on Thursday and will now be sent up to Albany for approval.

The bill itself does not specify the cost of a permit, or provide cap, but Squadron told CBSNews.com that the City Council and Department of Transportation would likely charge between $20 and $100.

“If it’ll be $2 this year, it’ll be $5 next year, and then it’ll become exorbitant,” predicted state Sen. Tony Avella, D-Bayside. “If this is going to be a backdoor way to raise funds, then I’m against it.”

Making people pay to park in their own neighborhood, said Avella, would be even more ludicrous than not being able to park.

“The devil is in the details,” he said, explaining that there would be some circumstances under which he would vote for it, but not if it would be an imposition on local businesses, for instance.

As it stands, the bill does have a short provision stating that commercial streets and adjacent properties will not be zoned for permit parking.

Squadron and the bill’s Albany sponsor, Assemblywoman Joan Millman, represent the neighborhoods around Atlantic Yards as well as downtown Brooklyn and Brooklyn Heights, where commuters routinely park.

Squadron’s bill has no co-sponsors from senators representing other city districts, Avella pointed out. The senator also said his Republican colleagues are likely to kill the bill to the disappointment of many who testified before the City Council’s Transportation Committee.

“Sometimes I get home from work and I have to wait two hours to get a parking spot,” testified a woman from Prospect Heights, Brooklyn who lived a block from the construction of Brooklyn’s Barclay Center. “This is going to get worse and worse. There’s going to be noise, air pollution. I have 21-month-old twins. This is going to be ridiculous.”

But others believe parking permits would be just another tax instituted by the city, that the “park and ride” problem would just move to the next neighborhood over, and that permits would make it difficult for people to drive to visit friends or run errands in other parts of their borough.

Revenues from the permits would be given to New York City Transit to improve subway and bus service.

Money from fines would go to the New York City general fund—a fact of which northeast Queens activist Bob Friedrich was all too aware.

“I can tell you right now, I am very much opposed to the street parking permit because it’s just another way the city will be taxing middle class homeowners,” said Friedrich, who is president of Glen Oaks Village.

Friedrich suspects that the permit zones may start of in limited areas, but said the areas and fees will “increase exponentially as the city needs resources.”

“I recognize that maybe some areas in the city that might have some concerns,” said Friedrich. “If they want a to create a parking permit, then it shouldn’t cost anything.”

WALTER RICKMAN November 05, 2011 at 07:40 PM
Tony Avella got it right, every single solution for every problem is to get more money out of someones pocket and then enhance it with issuing tickets. It's a disease. They need more money so they could spend more.
Arthur J caputo November 06, 2011 at 11:57 AM
Outrageous. The powers that be will think of anything to get more money out of your pocket. No wonder people have had enough and are protesting all over the country. Billions every day for illegal wars that benefit a few but nothing for the people who pay for these disgraceful wars.Now trying to make more money charging you to pay for parking in residential areas. . Remember when Gov Patterson wanted to tax our sodas? But Gov Cuomo doesn't want to end the tax cuts on millionaitres. Wake up out there and fight these repressive actions. Have they no shame?
ed rennard November 06, 2011 at 10:20 PM
New York City — All Counties Counties Amount of Vehicle Use Tax/Supplemental Fee The Tax/Fee Applies to: Bronx, Kings (Brooklyn), New York (Manhattan), Queens, Richmond (Staten Island) We already pay a NYC vehicle usage fee. ( See the note from the DMV website below.) Based on past performance, I suppose that they will (1) issue more permits than there are parking spaces on a given block and (2) allow city vehicles and those with NYC "permits" to park. The end result will be that you still will be driving around blocks from your destination looking for a space. This will be great for parking garages where you are at least sure of getting a parking space when you pay for it. From the DMV site All passenger vehicles: $30 for two years ($15 per year). All original registrations and renewals.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »